Sunday, March 18, 2012

Domestic Facility Risk Categorization and Risk-Based Inspection Frequencies


The FDA Food Safety Modernization Act (FSMA) created section 421 of the Federal Food, Drug, and Cosmetic Act (FD&C Act), which mandates FDA inspection frequency based on risk for domestic food facilities that are required to register under FD&C Act section 415. Specifically, section 421 mandates inspection frequencies based on a facility being identified as high-risk (HR) or non-high-risk (NHR). HR facilities must be inspected at least once in the first 5 years following enactment of FSMA and then once every 3 years. NHR facilities must be inspected at least once in the first 7 years following enactment and then once every 5 years. These inspection frequencies are a minimum and some firms may be inspected on a more frequent basis. 

FDA estimates the inventory for high-risk facilities at 22,325 and non-high-risk at 60,000.  For FY 2012, approximately 7,400 HR and 8,600 NHR facilities are planned for inspections. FDA plans to inspect HR facilities every 3 years although the new legislation provides an initial frequency mandate of inspecting each HR facility once in a 5-year period

Factors in Risk Categorization (FY 2011-13)
FSMA Identified Risk Factors*
Data Elements
Known safety risks of the food
  • Class 1 Recalls**
  • Foodborne illness outbreaks
Compliance history of a facility

Inspection Classifications
  • Facilities with significant violations
  • Facilities with a history of non-compliance
Facility’s hazard analysis and risk-based preventive controls
Limited data
Priority under section 801(h)(1)
 Applicable to foreign facilities only
Certifications for imported food
Programs not yet established
Any other criteria deemed necessary
  • Type of activity (establishment type)
  • Years since last inspection

The risk categorizations are expected to evolve as FDA gathers data on the new risk-based preventive controls and certifications are developed for imported foods.  The rigor and effectiveness of the facility’s hazard analysis and risk-based preventive controls will be an important factor in the future. At this time, FDA is basically determining risk in a three step process based on some of the above factors:

1. Known safety risks of the food - Whether facility packs, processes or holds a commodity that has been identified with known food safety risks; that is, food commodities associated with outbreaks and/or Class-I recalls.
2.  Years since last inspection. 
3.  Compliance history - History of significant violations or non-compliance.

Wednesday, March 07, 2012

AeroShot “Caffeine Inhaler”


FDA issued a warning letter to Breathable Foods Inc., makers of AeroShot, for false or misleading statements in the labeling of their “caffeine inhaler.” FDA finds the labeling false or misleading because the company claims use for both inhalation and ingestion. Breathable Foods claims AeroShot is designed to provide “breathable energy, anytime, anyplace.” The company also claims that its product is intended to be ingested by swallowing. FDA states that a product cannot be intended for both inhaling and swallowing, noting that human anatomy does not permit simultaneous inhalation and ingestion.

FDA continues that, “By definition, dietary supplements must be intended for ingestion.” See FDCA §§  201(ff)(2)(A) and 411(c)(1)(B) [21 U.S.C. §§ 321(ff)(2)(A) and 350(c)(1)(B)].  “A product intended for inhalation is not a dietary supplement.” Surprisingly, FDA did not state the consequence of failing to be a dietary supplement — as far as it is intended for caffeine inhalation, Aeroshot would be a drug and medical device.  I cover this in my book, Food Regulation: Law, Science, Policy, and Practice, in discussion of the case, United States v. Ten Cartons of Ener-B Nasal Gel.       

FDA is also concerned about AeroShot’s because of questions about its safety. Terms such as “caffeine inhaler” and “breathable energy” may encourage consumers to try to inhale AeroShot into their lungs. Caffeine is not normally inhaled into the lungs and the safety of doing so has not been well studied.  

The FDA also expressed concern about the use of AeroShot by children and adolescents.  The company’s website indicates that AeroShot is “not recommended for those under 18 years of age,” but the product label states that it is “not intended for people under 12.”  

FDA is also concerned about AeroShot website links to news articles and videos that refer to use of the product in conjunction with drinking alcohol.  While using caffeine when drinking may lead consumers to feel “less drunk,” it does not reduce blood alcohol levels. FDA states, “Data and expert opinion also indicate that caffeine decreases the perception of intoxication, meaning that individuals who consume caffeine along with alcohol may consume more alcohol than they otherwise would and become more intoxicated than they realize. At the same time, caffeine does not change blood alcohol content levels, and thus does not reduce the risk of harm associated with drinking alcohol.”


Neal Fortin is the author of Food Regulation: Law, Science, Policy, and Practice, and he is Professor and Director of the Michigan State University Institute for Food Laws and Regulations, where he teaches online courses in Food Regulation in the United States, International Food Law, and Codex Alimentarius. 

Sunday, February 26, 2012

"Soy Torture" of Prisoners


The Weston Price Foundation is backing lawsuits by prison inmates being poisoned, tortured, and irreparably harmed — by soy in the prison food.  For years, rumors floated about of saltpeter in prison diets. Mel Brooks made jokes about it.  But now — soy in prison diets! Among other things, soy has been accused of causing low sperm counts.

The lawsuits allege that the soy caused acne, insomnia, weight gain, and additional ailments.  As such, the complainants say soy in the prison diet is cruel and unusual punishment in violation of their Eighth Amendment rights.  

I am not making this up.  See, Askin v. Quaker Oats Co., No. 1:11CV00111 2011, WL 145369 (N.D. Ill. Jan. 7, 2011) and Weston A. Price Foundation Press Release, Oct. 25, 2011. 

Soy vey!

Friday, February 24, 2012

FDA's New Record Access Authority


FDA published an Interim Final Rule to modify their regulations on the establishment, maintenance, and availability of records. Before passage of the Food Safety and Modernization Act (FSMA), section 414(a) of the FD&C Act provided the Secretary of Health and Human Services (and by delegation FDA) with access to records relating to food that was reasonably believed to be adulterated and present a threat of serious adverse health consequences or death to humans or animals. FSMA expanded FDA’s records access authority to records relating to include any other article of food that the Secretary reasonably believes is likely to be affected in a similar manner and foods which FDA considers a reasonable probability that the use of or exposure to the article of food will cause serious adverse health consequences or death to humans or animals. 

Although the majority of the rule tracks the FSMA language, one important addition has been made.  Records are required to be “provided must be made available as soon as possible, not to exceed 24 hours from the time of receipt of the official request.”   

21CFR § 1.361 What are the record availability requirements?
When FDA has a reasonable belief that an article of food, and any other article of food that FDA reasonably believes is likely to be affected in a similar manner, is adulterated and presents a threat of serious adverse health consequences or death to humans or animals, or when FDA believes that there is a reasonable probability that the use of or exposure to an article of food, and any other article of food that FDA reasonably believes is likely to be affected in a similar manner, will cause serious adverse health consequences or death to humans or animals, any records and other information accessible to FDA under section 414 or 704(a) of the Federal Food, Drug, and Cosmetic Act (21 U.S.C. 350c and 374(a)) must be made readily available for inspection and photocopying or other means of reproduction. Such records and other information must be made available as soon as possible, not to exceed 24 hours from the time of receipt of the official request, from an officer or employee duly designated by the Secretary of Health and Human Services who presents appropriate credentials and a written notice.

FDA’s record access authority under section 414 is separate from previously existing records access authority provided in commodity specific regulations, such as the Low-Acid Canned Food regulations (21 CFR part 113), the Acidified Food regulations (21 CFR part 114), the Juice Hazard Analysis and Critical Control Point (HACCP) Systems regulations (21 CFR part 120), the Fish and Fishery Products regulations (21 CFR part 123), and the Infant Formula regulations (21 CFR part 106). FSMA did not amend these commodity specific record access requirements.  

FDA’s records access authority under sections 414(a) and 704(a) applies to both domestic and foreign persons (excluding farms and restaurants) who manufacture, process, pack, transport, distribute, receive, hold, or import articles of food when the circumstances in section 414(a)(1) or (2) of the FD&C Act are met. 

FDA requests to access and copy records are most likely to occur when FDA becomes aware of reportable food reports, as defined in section 417(a)(2) of the FD&C Act [21 U.S.C. 350f(a)(2)], foodborne outbreaks, epidemiological evidence implicates a food causing illness or death, product recalls, adverse event reports, and consumer complaints.

FDA’s authority under FD&C Act §§ 414(a) and 704(a) applies to records that are required to be kept by regulation under section 414(b), as well as any other records related to the manufacture, processing, packing, transporting, distribution, receipt, holding, or importation of the food believed to be affected and any other article of food believed to be affected in a similar manner.  Examples of records that FDA can access and copy include:
•       Manufacturing records
•       Raw materials (ingredients and packaging) receipt records
•       Product distribution records
•       Product inventory records
•       Test records
•       Recall records
•       Reportable food records      
•       Customer distribution lists
•       Complaint and adverse event records

FDA's authority to access records under sections 414(a) and 704(a) of the FD&C Act does not apply to records from farms, as defined in 21 CFR 1.328, records from restaurants, as defined in 21 CFR 1.328, or records relating to food that is within the exclusive jurisdiction of the Federal Meat Inspection Act (21 U.S.C. 601 et seq.), the Poultry Products Inspection Act (21 U.S.C. 451 et seq.), or the Egg Products Inspection Act (21 U.S.C. 1031 et seq.)  FDA's authority to access records also does not apply to:
·      Recipes, as defined in 21 CFR 1.328 (but a list of the ingredients used to manufacture a food, without quantity information and manufacturing instructions, is not a recipe.)
·      Financial data
·      Pricing data
·      Personnel data
·      Research data
·      Sales data other than shipment data regarding sales 

The refusal to permit access to or copying of records requested under section 414(a) of the FD&C Act is a prohibited act under section 301(e) of the FD&C Act [21 U.S.C. 331(e)]. In response to such a refusal, FDA may initiate civil or criminal action, as necessary, including:
•       Suspension of the food facility’s registration, thus preventing the firm from importing or exporting food or introducing food into interstate or intrastate commerce
•       Administrative detention of the food to control its movement
•       Seizure of the food
•       Issuance of a mandatory recall order for the food
•       Injunction against the firm 
•       Refuse admission of food offered for import into U.S. commerce
FDA has issued two guidance documents:



Neal Fortin is the author of Food Regulation: Law, Science, Policy, and Practice, and he is Professor and Director of the Michigan State University Institute for Food Laws and Regulations, where he teaches online courses in Food Regulation in the United States, International Food Law, and Codex Alimentarius. 

    Monday, February 06, 2012

    Federal Meat Inspection Act Preempts California Law on Non-Ambulatory Animals


    In a unanimous opinion, the U.S. Supreme Court held that the Federal Meat Inspection Act (FMIA) expressly preempts a California law that dictated slaughterhouses must reject non-ambulatory pigs.

     The California law, section 599f of the California state penal code, prohibited slaughterhouse purchase or sale any non-ambulatory livestock and prohibited the processing of meat from non-ambulatory livestock for human food. This law was adopted in 2008 after the Humane Society released an undercover video showing workers at a Westland/Hallmark Meat Co. slaughterhouse in California dragging, kicking, and electro- shocking sick and disabled cows in an effort to move them. The video led the federal government to institute the largest beef recall in U. S. history in order to prevent consumption of meat from diseased animals.

    First enacted in 1906, the FMIA was amended in 1978 to require all slaughterhouses comply with the standards for humane handling and slaughter of animals set out in the Humane Methods of Slaughter Act of 1958 (72 Stat. 862, 7 U.S.C. §1901 et seq.). The FMIA express preempts state laws “with respect to premises, facilities and operations of any establishment at which inspection is provided under . . . this [FMIA] which are in addition to, or different than those made under [FMIA]” (21 U. S. C. § 678).

     “The FMIA’s preemption clause sweeps widely—and in so doing, blocks the applications of §599f challenged here. The clause prevents a State from imposing any additional or different—even if non-conflicting—requirements that fall within the scope of the Act and concern a slaughterhouse’s facilities or operations. And at every turn §599f imposes additional or different requirements on swine slaughterhouses: It compels them to deal with nonambulatory pigs on their premises in ways that the federal Act and regulations do not. In essence, California’s statute substitutes a new regulatory scheme for the one the FSIS uses. Where under federal law a slaughterhouse may take one course of action in handling a nonambulatory pig, under state law the slaughterhouse must take another.” 565 U. S. ____ (2012).


    Neal Fortin is the author of Food Regulation: Law, Science, Policy, and Practice, and he is Professor and Director of the Michigan State University Institute for Food Laws and Regulations, where he teaches online courses in Food Regulation in the United States, International Food Law, and Codex Alimentarius. 

    Thursday, January 12, 2012

    Get Poisoned for Free


    Bill Marler, guest instructor for the Institute for Food Laws and Regulations, is offering to give a book to each new person who subscribes to his blog (up to 200 hardcover books).  Just subscribe here and email Mr. Marler your address at bmarler@marlerclark.com.

    The book, Jeff Benedict's Poisoned, is a great read.  So is Bill Marler's blog. Win Win.




    Monday, December 26, 2011

    FDA Withdraws Proposals to Ban Antibiotics in Animal Feed


    Maryn McKenna wrote in Wired, “News: FDA Won’t Act Against Ag Antibiotic Use,” about the FDA’s withdrawal of two 1977 proposals to withdraw certain approved uses of penicillin and tetracyclines in animal feeds because of the concerns over antibiotic resistant bacteria:
    With no notice other than a holiday-eve posting in the Federal Register, the US Food and Drug Administration has reneged on its long-stated intention to compel large-scale agriculture to curb over-use of agricultural antibiotics, which it had planned to do by reversing its approval for putting penicillin and tetracyclines in feed….
    FDA represents this move as a change in tactics because the agency lacks the resources to move forward with a regulatory ban. Instead, the FDA is hoping for voluntary reductions in risky uses of antibiotics in animal feed. In the Federal Register posting, the agency states, “FDA is optimistic that its proposed strategy to achieve the judicious use of all medically important antimicrobials, as set out in draft [guidance document], will be successful . . .”  Perhaps after 34 years of failure, a new FDA strategy is needed.

    Friday, December 16, 2011

    Are Genetically Engineered Foods "Natural"?


    A lawsuit claiming misleading advertising, unfair competition, and breach of express warranty has been filed in California against Frito-Lay chips advertised as “All Natural ingredients” while allegedly “made from genetically modified plants and organisms.”  

    Gengo v. Frito-Lay N. Am., Inc., No. 11-10322 (U.S. Dist. Ct., C.D. Cal., filed December 14, 2011).


    Neal Fortin is the author of Food Regulation: Law, Science, Policy, and Practice, and he is Professor and Director of the Michigan State University Institute for Food Laws and Regulations, where he teaches online courses in Food Regulation in the United States, International Food Law, and Codex Alimentarius. 

    Thursday, December 15, 2011

    Vulnerabilities in FDA’S Oversight of State Food Facility Inspections


    Vulnerabilities in FDA’S Oversight of State Food Facility Inspections, an Office of Inspector General (OIG) report released December 2011, identifies significant weaknesses in FDA's oversight of state food inspections on which FDA increasingly relies. In eight States, FDA failed to ensure that the required number of inspections was completed, and FDA paid for many inspections that were incomplete.

    In addition, FDA did not ensure that all inspections were properly classified or that all inspection violations were remedied. FDA failed to complete the required number of audits in one-third of the States with inspection contracts (14 of 41 states). Additionally, the audits in 10 States revealed systemic problems that needed to be corrected; however, FDA initiated corrective action in only 4 of these 10 States.

    Neal Fortin is the author of Food Regulation: Law, Science, Policy, and Practice, and he is Professor and Director of the Michigan State University Institute for Food Laws and Regulations, where he teaches online courses in Food Regulation in the United States, International Food Law, and Codex Alimentarius. 

    Monday, November 28, 2011

    GAO Report, FDA: Better Coordination Could Enhance Efforts to Address Economic Adulteration and Protect the Public Health

    This Government Accountability Office (GAO) report examines FDA’s approaches to detecting and preventing economic adulteration of food and medical products. The report notes the challenges FDA faces in detecting and preventing such adulteration, but concludes, "FDA may not be making the best use of its scarce resources.” The full report is available here.


    Neal Fortin is the author of Food Regulation: Law, Science, Policy, and Practice, and he is Professor and Director of the Michigan State University Institute for Food Laws and Regulations, where he teaches online courses in Food Regulation in the United States, International Food Law, and Codex Alimentarius. 

    Wednesday, November 23, 2011

    WTO rules against U.S. country-of-origin labels

    According to the Associated Press, the World Trade Organization (WTO) has ruled that U.S. "country-of-origin" labels on cattle and hog exports from Canada and Mexico violate international rules. In late 2009, the WTO opened an investigation into U.S. labeling rules at the request of Canada and Mexico. The country-of-origin labeling regulation took effect in 2008. Canada and Mexico each claimed their livestock industries were hurt by a sharp drop in U.S. cattle and hog imports because the labeling raised the costs and discouraged imports of their produce.

    Under country-of-origin labeling, foreign cattle and pigs had to be segregated in U.S. feedlots and packing plants, prompting some firms to deal only with American livestock. Foreign animals also were required to have more documentation about where they came from and, in the case of cattle, had to have tags that indicated they were free of mad-cow disease.

    More information is available here.

    European Union's Food Information to Consumers Regulation

    Since the vote of the European Parliament in July, we have been waiting for the EU Food Information Regulation to be issued in final form. It was published in the Official Journal (L) of the European Union on November 22. The citation is Reg. (EU) 1169/2011. OJ(L) 304/18, 22 Nov 2011.


    This Regulation revises 20 years of EP and EC Directives and Regulations. Among the changes, the regulation requires nutrition label declaration of the "Big 7"—energy, fat, saturated fat, carbohydrates, sugars, protein, and salt by Dec. 13, 2016. There are also new rules on allergen labeling and legibility. The regulation introduces a minimum font size of 1.2 mm for all mandatory label information, and 0.9 mm for products whose packaging has a largest surface of less than 80 square cm.

    The full text of the Regulation (66 pages), European Union's Food Information to Consumers Regulation, is available at: www.food-label-compliance.com. Hat tip to Charles Woodhouse.

    Friday, November 11, 2011

    Cooks Lie About Thermometers


    Nancy Shute of NPR's Food Blog wrote in Why We Lie About Using Food Thermometers, "Just 20 percent of Americans say they regularly use a food thermometer to make sure they have cooked food safely, according to a new survey . . . And food safety experts say that a fair number of those people were probably fibbing."

              With the holidays coming, this is a good time to buy some good digital thermometers and give them to kith and kin. Some will give you an odd smile, throw it in the back of a drawer, never to see daylight again. Some will be prodded to cook safety, and the life you save could be your own.


              I like the CDN ProAccurate models, in particular the CDN DTQ450X ProAccurate Quick-Read Thermometer. Whatever model you get, look for a fast read, accurate digital thermometer. Take multiple readings. It can be hard to find the coldest point. And make sure the coldest part reaches the temperature recommended by the USDA.
     




    Saturday, September 24, 2011

    FDA Law Blog: New Twist In “Natural” Lawsuit


    FDA Law Blog: New Twist In “Natural” Lawsuit by Riëtte van Laack reports on another class action suit regarding “natural” food labeling claims. The defendants include Kashi Co. and its general manager, as well as Kashi’s parent Kellogg Co. and its President. "Plaintiffs claim defendants falsely and misleadingly labeled virtually all Kashi products as 'all natural' or containing nothing artificial even though the products allegedly do not conform to applicable federal regulations and policies on 'natural.'”


    Neal Fortin is the author of Food Regulation: Law, Science, Policy, and Practice, and he is Professor and Director of the Michigan State University Institute for Food Laws and Regulations, where he teaches online courses in Food Regulation in the United States, International Food Law, and Codex Alimentarius. 

    Thursday, September 15, 2011

    Nutrition Labeling of Single-Ingredient Meats Coming January 1

    The USDA Food Safety Inspection Service (FSIS) published a final rule that will required nutritional labeling on major cuts of single-ingredient raw meat and poultry products and on all ground or chopped meat and poultry products (unless an exemption applies). The rule also establishes criteria for making a lean percentage statement. The new rule takes effect on January 1, 2012. FSIS has published an informational Web site that includes the final rule, questions and answers, and a PowerPoint presentation. 

    Public Health Law Research Annual Meeting

    Public Health Law Research is holding the 2012 Public Health Law Research Annual Meeting, "Public Health Law: Targets of Opportunity," January 18-20, 2012, in New Orleans. The conference will highlight research that provides evidence about how law can be used to improve population health; abstracts are being accepted until November 15, 2011.

    Wednesday, September 14, 2011

    USDA Declaring Six Serotypes of E. coli as Adulterants

    The U.S. Department of Agriculture (USDA) today is declaring six other serogroups of Shiga toxin-producing E. coli (STEC) (O26, O45, O103, O111, O121, and O145). The Agency has determined that they, as well as O157:H7, are adulterants of non-intact raw beef products and product components within the meaning of the Federal Meat Inspection Act (FMIA).


    Beginning in March 2012, any raw ground beef, its components, and tenderized steaks that test positive for non-O157:H7 Shiga-toxin producing E.coli strains O26, O103, O45, O111, O121 and O145 will be banned from being sold for public consumption.


    The Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC) identified these particular serogroups of non-O157:H7 Shiga-toxin producing E.coli, or non-O157 STEC, as those responsible for the greatest numbers of non-O157 STEC illnesses, hospitalizations, and deaths in the United States.

    Monday, September 12, 2011

    Lessons From Europe in the E. Coli Outbreak


    Perhaps we have focused too much on traceability and should put more resources into epidemiology. Perhaps the imbalance is resources to traceability is because it provides concrete results that can immediately be demonstrated and showcased. In addition, large businesses already invested in traceback ability. Traceability is important, but traceability matters little if the epidemiology is incorrect or incomplete.


    Jim Prevor wrote, "People are dropping dead from eating food and we are too cowardly to suggest irradiation. This is bizarre. The failure of public health authorities to demand the use of irradiation is evidence of a politically influenced establishment that is not, in fact, putting public health first."  


    Of course, public resistance to the technology is also a reason for underutilization of irradiation. However, there is no doubt that irradiation of produce that is eaten raw could save many lives. For more information on this topic, visit the NPR website Irradiation Underused To Fight E. Coli in Foods. 




    Friday, September 09, 2011

    Proposed Foodborne Illness Reduction Act of 2011 (S. 1529)

    Senator Gillibrand introduced bill S.1529 in the U.S. Senate yesterday. The bill is titled as the "Foodborne Illness Reduction Act of 2011''.

    Extension of Comment Period on FDA's Guidance for NDI Notifications

    Today FDA published in the Federal Register a notice granting a 60-day extension (until December 2, 2011) for comments on the FDA's draft guidance on New Dietary Ingredient ("NDI") notifications, which the Agency issued on July 5, 2011. More information is available here.